J.J. McCarthy completions: hit rate and tonight's fair price
J.J. McCarthy (NYG) has gone over 19.5 completions in 2 of his last 10 games and 2 of 5 this season. Tonight the books have him at 19.5: the sharp consensus makes the over 51% and the under 49%, best over price +100 at ESPN BET, best under -114 at FanDuel.
Fair = the sharp consensus at that line with the vig removed, calibrated per side. A book price longer than the fair number's break-even is value; shorter is not.
Hit rate at 19.5
Window
Games
Over
Under
Push
Over %
Avg
This season
5
2
2
0
50%
13.20
Last 5
5
2
2
0
50%
13.20
Last 10
10
2
7
0
22%
13.20
Last 20
15
3
11
0
21%
13.73
Home
7
2
5
0
29%
15.86
Away
8
1
6
0
14%
11.88
Every game on record
15
3
11
0
21%
13.73
By season
Season
Games
Over
Under
Over %
Avg
2026
5
2
2
50%
13.20
2025
10
1
9
10%
14.00
Last 10 games
12
16
15
9
14
0
11
20
12
23
Date
Opp
Completions
Result
Score
2026-11-12
vs WSH
23
over
21-24
2026-11-08
@ PHI
12
miss
19-11
2026-10-25
@ HOU
20
over
27-21
2026-10-18
vs NO
11
miss
27-34
2026-10-11
@ WSH
—
27-27
2026-01-04
vs GB
14
miss
16-3
2025-12-21
@ NYG
9
miss
16-13
2025-12-14
@ DAL
15
miss
34-26
2025-12-07
vs WSH
16
miss
31-0
2025-11-23
@ GB
12
miss
6-23
Run this lookup yourself. The Lab prices any line you type against the sharp consensus and shows the hit rate with any filter: season, opponent, home or away, last N. Three free lookups a day; Lab Pro is unlimited. Open the LabLab Pro